to estimate withholding, sell-to-cover shares, and shortfall
Equity Compensation · IRC §83(a) · IRS Pub 15 §7 · TY 2026
Estimate the tax on a restricted stock unit vesting event under IRC §83(a). Computes ordinary-income inclusion at vest FMV, federal supplemental withholding, FICA, the sell-to-cover share count, and the under-withholding gap when your marginal bracket exceeds the 22 percent flat supplemental rate.
Want the full rules, examples, edge cases, and planning context behind this calculation? Read the companion guide.
Read the RSU Tax Guide →When your RSUs vest, the fair market value of the shares becomes ordinary wage income under IRC §83(a). Your employer withholds federal income tax at the supplemental wage rate of 22 percent (37 percent on amounts above $1 million per employer per year), Social Security tax (6.2 percent up to the 2026 wage base of $184,500), Medicare (1.45 percent), and Additional Medicare Tax (0.9 percent over $200K single or $250K MFJ). Most companies use sell-to-cover, selling enough shares at vest to remit withholding. The 22 percent flat rate routinely under-withholds for employees in the 24 percent bracket and above; the shortfall surfaces at filing as a balance due.
| Item | Value | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Federal supplemental withholding rate (vest income ≤ $1M from one employer) | 22% | Confirmed |
| Federal supplemental rate above $1M (per employer, calendar year) | 37% | Confirmed |
| Social Security rate (employee share) | 6.2% | Confirmed |
| 2026 Social Security wage base | $184,500 | Confirmed |
| Medicare rate (employee share) | 1.45% | Confirmed |
| Additional Medicare Tax rate | 0.9% | Confirmed |
| Additional Medicare threshold: Single / HOH | $200,000 | Confirmed |
| Additional Medicare threshold: MFJ | $250,000 | Confirmed |
| Additional Medicare threshold: MFS | $125,000 | Confirmed |
| Employer mandatory Additional Medicare withholding threshold | $200,000 (per employee, regardless of filing status) | Confirmed |
| Governing statute (vest as ordinary income) | IRC §83(a) | Confirmed |
| 83(b) election availability for normal RSUs | Not available (RSUs are an unfunded promise, not transferred property) | Confirmed |
| Vest cost basis for capital gains on later sale | FMV at vest (already in W-2 Box 1) | Confirmed |
| Long-term capital gains holding period | More than 1 year after vest date | Confirmed |
| State withholding (varies by state) | See your state DOR | Provisional |
This calculator applies IRC §83(a) for vest-date inclusion and IRS Publication 15 section 7 for supplemental wage withholding for tax year 2026. The calculation runs in five sequential steps. For the full statutory framework, why an 83(b) election does not apply to RSUs, double-trigger mechanics for private companies, and post-vest capital gains rules, see our RSU Tax Guide.
At vest, the substantial risk of forfeiture lapses. Under IRC §83(a), the FMV of the shares at that time is included in the employee's gross income for the year. Vest income is reported on Form W-2 in Box 1 (federal wages), Box 3 (Social Security wages, up to the wage base), Box 5 (Medicare wages, no cap), and is also typically broken out in Box 14 with a code such as "RSU" for transparency.
Vest income = Number of shares vesting × FMV per share at vest
The employer withholds federal income tax on the vest using the supplemental wage rate. For 2026 this is 22 percent on cumulative supplemental wages up to $1 million from that employer in the calendar year, and 37 percent on any amount above $1 million. RSU vest income counts as supplemental wages for this purpose under IRS Publication 15 section 7.
If (YTD supplemental + vest income) ≤ $1,000,000: Federal withholding = Vest income × 22%
If (YTD supplemental + vest income) > $1,000,000: Federal withholding = 22% on the portion up to $1M + 37% on the excess
Social Security tax (6.2 percent) applies to the vest income up to the 2026 wage base of $184,500, combined with regular wages and prior supplemental wages. Once your combined YTD wages reach $184,500, no further Social Security tax is withheld. Medicare tax (1.45 percent) applies to the entire vest with no wage cap.
Social Security withholding = MIN(Vest income, MAX(0, $184,500 − YTD Wages)) × 6.2%
Medicare withholding = Vest income × 1.45%
Under IRC §3101(b)(2), an additional 0.9 percent Medicare tax applies to wages above $200,000 single/HOH, $250,000 MFJ, or $125,000 MFS. Employers must begin withholding the 0.9 percent once an employee's calendar-year wages from that employer exceed $200,000, regardless of filing status. Final liability is reconciled on Form 8959 with the individual return.
Additional Medicare withholding = MAX(0, (YTD Wages + Vest income) − Filing Threshold) × 0.9%
Under sell-to-cover, the equity broker sells just enough vested shares to remit total federal supplemental withholding plus FICA to the employer's payroll system. The number of shares sold is computed by dividing total withholding by FMV per share, rounded up to the next whole share to avoid a short remittance.
Shares sold to cover = CEILING(Total federal + FICA withholding / FMV per share)
Net shares retained = Vest shares − Shares sold to cover
Sell-to-cover is the default in 90 percent of public-company RSU plans because it eliminates the cash-flow burden on the employee. Sell-all converts the equity to cash with no capital gain. Hold-all is the rarest option and usually requires the employee to send the employer a check on the vest date.
Example 2 shows the standard high-earner trap: a $200,000 vest withheld at 22 percent leaves a roughly $20,000 federal balance due if the employee is in the 32 percent bracket. Add California state tax (10.23 percent supplemental) and the actual cash impact at filing can exceed $40,000 unless covered by quarterly estimated payments. Example 3 shows the opposite case: a junior employee in the 12 percent bracket is over-withheld and recovers part at filing.
At LMN Tax Inc, the question we hear most from tech and finance clients in March is "why do I owe so much when I have W-2 withholding?" The answer is almost always RSU under-withholding. A senior engineer with $300,000 of base salary and $250,000 of vested RSUs in the year is in the 32 percent federal bracket. The base salary is withheld correctly via W-4 tables. The RSU vest is withheld at the 22 percent supplemental flat rate. The $25,000 federal shortfall on the RSU vest (10-point gap on $250,000) is invisible until the return is prepared. The fix is mechanical and effective: a Q4 estimated payment through IRS Direct Pay or a one-time W-4 extra-withholding bump on the December paycheck. For California-based clients we add the 10.23 percent state bonus rate; the under-withholding rarely matches CA marginal either, so a Franchise Tax Board estimated payment is usually the same conversation. The trap is that the shortfall feels like a tax surprise; it is actually a withholding-design feature of Pub 15.
If your marginal federal bracket is 24 percent or above, the 22 percent supplemental withholding is structurally short. Make a Q4 estimated tax payment through IRS Direct Pay sized to (Vest income × (Marginal rate − 22%)), or update your Form W-4 Step 4(c) to add extra withholding on regular paychecks. The same logic applies to the bonus side of supplemental wages; see our Bonus Tax Calculator.
For the full statutory framework on RSUs, why an 83(b) election does not apply, double-trigger mechanics for private-company employees, and post-vest capital gains rules, read our RSU Tax Guide.
If you also receive cash bonuses from the same employer, total federal withholding on combined supplemental wages still uses the 22 percent flat rate (or 37 percent above $1 million per employer per year). Project total annual liability through the W-4 Withholding Calculator and the Bonus Tax Withholding Guide.
If the vest will affect your anticipated refund or balance due, project your IRS deposit timing using the Refund Date Estimator after you file. For context on what drives the IRS 21-day processing window, see the IRS Refund Timeline Guide.